Share this Tribute

Let the family know you
care by sharing this tribute.

Donna Plummer Mitchell


Donna Plummer Mitchell passed away on June 29, 2020 with her daughters by her side. She was born in Evansville, IN to John and Katherine (Kitty) Plummer. She was a loving mother and grandmother who loved playing games of all kinds, doing needlework, but, most of all, spending time with her precious grandchildren. She is survived by her daughters, Julie (Nick) Malagreca and Jackie Mitchell, and by grandchildren, Katie, Gabby, Nicholas, and Michael. A memorial service will be held at Our Lady of Peace Church, 20 E. Dominion, Columbus, OH, on August 22 at 11:00am, followed by a reception at the family’s home. Masks required please. Burial will take place in Evansville, IN at a later date. Donations may be made in her honor to the Rheumatoid Arthritis Foundation.  Please visit www.OhioCremation.org to leave the family an online condolence.

Share this Tribute

Let the family know you
care by sharing this tribute.

Leave a condolence

Email addresses will not be displayed on this site.


  • Pat Jost says:

    Julie & Jackie, our hearts go out to you both. I am going to miss my best friend. May she Rest In Peace. May you both find peace knowing how much she loved you. Wish we could be there with you. Love, Pat & Chet

  • Pat Jost says:

    Julie & Jackie, our hearts go out to you! We have so many fond memories—West Haven Dr., Disney World, playing cards & visiting in Monticello as well as in Columbus. Those are just a few.
    We hope your memories will help you both find some peace. Wish we could be with you at this time but we’ll see you in Evansville. Love, Pat & Chet

  • Pat Jost says:

    Julie & Jackie, our hearts go out to you! We have so many fond memories—West Haven Dr., Disney World, playing cards & visiting in Monticello as well as in Columbus. Those are just a few.
    We hope your memories will help you both find some peace. Wish we could be with you at this time but we’ll see you in Evansville. Sending our love & sympathy.

  • Terri Williams says:

    Julie-
    So sorry to hear about your Mom’s passing. May prayers of comfort and strength guide you through this time of grieving. You were a loving daughter and now you have a Guardian Angel.
    My deepest sympathy,
    Terri Williams

5464 N High St,
Columbus, OH 43214

(614) 840-0900
FAX: (614) 840-0999

9 Chambers Rd,
Mansfield, OH 44906

Copyright © 2019 Ohio Cremation & Memorial Society